Nutrition myths during pregnancy: what’s true, what’s outdated, what you can ignore - part 1

SUBSTACK • March 17, 2026

If you’re pregnant (or trying to be), chances are you’ve already been flooded with nutrition advice - some of it helpful, a lot of it confusing and some of it downright contradictory. One person tells you to eat for two. Another warns you not to gain “too much.” Someone sends you a list of forbidden foods that reads like a legal document. Another swears their grandmother did the opposite and “everyone turned out fine.”

It’s exhausting.

Nutrition during pregnancy has become a magnet for myths, half-truths and outdated rules that don’t reflect how bodies actually work or how women actually live. Let’s clear some of that noise and focus on what’s real, what’s old and what you can safely stop worrying about.

The most common nutrition myths women hear

Let’s start with the greatest hits.

“You’re eating for two.”

This one refuses to die. While energy needs do increase during pregnancy, especially in the second and third trimesters, it’s not a free-for-all. You don’t need double portions of everything from day one and you also don’t need to keep intake artificially low out of fear.

“Weight gain should be minimal if you’re healthy.”

This myth shows up quietly but does a lot of damage. Pregnancy weight gain includes a baby, placenta, amniotic fluid, increased blood volume, breast tissue and fat stores that support pregnancy and breastfeeding. Treating weight gain as a personal failure misses the point entirely.

“Cravings mean you’re out of control or doing something wrong.”

Cravings are often your body asking for energy, carbs, salt or familiarity - especially when hormones, nausea and fatigue are in play. They’re not a moral issue.

“You must avoid all ‘bad’ foods.”

This usually translates into long lists of banned items that grow longer every year. Some cautions are valid. Many are exaggerated. The fear-based tone is the problem.

“If you eat perfectly, you’ll have a perfect pregnancy.”

This is the most subtle myth - and maybe the most harmful. Nutrition supports pregnancy; it doesn’t guarantee outcomes.

Thanks for reading part 1 of my 3-part mini-series! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.